• 5 weeks ago
In 1945, America held a nuclear monopoly, the strongest navy and air force on Earth, and nearly half of the world’s GDP, so why didn’t it strike the USSR before the Cold War began? This historical analysis digs into the real obstacles behind a hypothetical US-Soviet War, from the limits of the B-29 to the still-developing B-36 and the sheer difficulty of carrying out a surprise atomic attack.

The video explains why nuking Moscow or Leningrad would not have guaranteed victory, especially with the Red Army’s numerical advantage in Europe, Soviet anti-aircraft defenses, and the vast distances of Soviet industry east of the Urals. It also covers British and American war planning, including Operation Unthinkable, and the grim calculations that made a first strike politically and militarily unpalatable.

For viewers interested in World War 2 history, Cold War origins, military history, and alternate history analysis, this is a sharp look at the moment when the postwar world could have gone in a very different direction. It’s ideal for fans of history documentaries, strategic warfare breakdowns, and deep dives into atomic bomb planning and superpower rivalry.

SEO: World War 2 history, Cold War history, US and USSR relations, Operation Unthinkable, atomic bomb strategy, military history documentary, alternate history, Soviet Union analysis, nuclear weapons history, and postwar geopolitics. Great for history listeners, documentary fans, and anyone searching for World War 2 and Cold War transition stories.

Category

📚
Learning
Transcript
00:00Let us, for a brief moment, return to the not-too-distant world of 1945, when Britain gloriously triumphed over
00:08the evil forces of fascism.
00:11Admittedly, Britain didn't win alone. As the saying goes, the Second World War was won with Soviet blood, American steel,
00:20and British intelligence.
00:22But among the three victors, it is without a doubt the USA that came out on top.
00:28As the only major country unravaged by the war, America represented a staggering 50% of the world's GDP in
00:36the summer of 1945.
00:38It was in sole possession of by far the strongest navy and air force on Earth.
00:44But perhaps even more importantly, it held an absolute monopoly on nuclear weapons, having just demonstrated their potency in Japan
00:54twice.
00:54So with such hegemonic power, why didn't America stomp its future arch-rival, the USSR, out of existence right there
01:04and then?
01:05And even if not immediately, the Soviets didn't get their own nukes until 1949, leaving the US with plenty of
01:11time to defeat not just them, but perhaps all enemies of capitalism across the globe,
01:16finally uniting the Earth under the one true economic system.
01:22Megalomaniac daydreaming aside, let us indulge this hypothetical.
01:27What would a US-Soviet war have looked like in 1945?
01:31Well, for a start, it wouldn't have been nuclear.
01:35For while America had the knowledge of how to produce atomic bombs, actually making them was a painfully tedious process.
01:42Even towards the end of 1945, the US had zero nuclear bombs ready for deployment,
01:50and was only producing around one and a half nuclear cores per month, which ignores all the additional assembly time
01:56required.
01:57In the backdrop of this nuclear deficiency, in Europe, the Soviets held a major numerical advantage,
02:03with three times as many soldiers and twice as many tanks and tactical aircraft than all of the other allies
02:11combined.
02:12The only category where Britain and America held any sort of advantage was in strategic aircraft,
02:20which, incidentally, is quite useful because that's what you need to drop atomic bombs.
02:26But that still wouldn't have made nuking Moscow a cakewalk.
02:31Remember, unlike Japan, the USSR of 1945 had a vast arsenal of anti-aircraft weapons
02:39and a seasoned air force that would make nuclear bomber missions far more difficult to execute.
02:45But even if the US managed to successfully launch a surprise attack on the USSR
02:52by, say, nuking Moscow and Leningrad, the Red Army would still have no trouble at all rolling over the Allies
02:59in Western Europe.
03:01After all, it's mostly flat terrain, and that's hard to defend.
03:06The only places where America and Britain could plausibly hold back the Soviets
03:11would be certain Atlantic coastal pockets, like the ones the Nazis held after D-Day,
03:16and perhaps mountainous Italy, but generally any place where Allied naval dominance could overcome the Red Army's firepower.
03:25It's plausible that America's industrial advantage could have eventually tipped the scales after years of total war,
03:33but suffice to say, the cost of defeating the USSR in such a manner would have been entirely unpalatable to
03:39the Western public.
03:40These, in fact, were the very conclusions of the British Joint Planning Staff
03:45when they, at the behest of Sir Winston Churchill, explored a hypothetical war with the Soviet Union in May 1945.
03:54The plan was aptly named Operation Unthinkable,
03:59and when the Labour Party won the 1945 general election in Britain and removed Churchill from power,
04:05the plan was outright discarded.
04:08But, across the pond, the Americans were pondering their own approach to war with the Soviets.
04:15Truth be told, the Americans were pondering a lot of things in 1945.
04:20It was an eventful year, after all.
04:23So eventful, in fact, that our dear friends over at Magellan TV have made an exclusive documentary about it.
04:31Witness the final hours of the Third Reich, the stirring fire of decolonization,
04:37and the first frigid shadows of the Cold War in unparalleled detail.
04:44You'll find that Magellan TV offers a curated selection of some of the finest documentaries ever made,
04:51including other ones related to the Second World War that we may very well cover here in future.
04:57Beyond history, Magellan TV boasts a vast library of over 3,000 documentaries
05:04on topics ranging from science and technology to nature, society, and more.
05:10It is entirely ad-free, and can be accessed in pristine 4K resolution across all your devices, wherever you are.
05:19And here's the best part.
05:20As a special courtesy to SideQuest viewers, Magellan TV are offering you a 30-day free trial,
05:28if you visit the link in the description, or scan the QR code on screen now.
05:33But let's get back to 1945, specifically September 1945, less than two weeks after Japan's formal surrender.
05:43At this time, the U.S. Army Air Force circulated a top-secret draft that outlined how the Soviet Union
05:51might be defeated.
05:53Like the British, the Americans understood that anything short of a decisive surprise attack
05:58would lead to a years-long total war with the Soviets.
06:02So, in preparation for such a first strike,
06:05they produced this wonderfully detailed map of all strategic targets in the Soviet Union.
06:11You'll notice quite a few of them are beyond the Ural Mountains,
06:15where Stalin had relocated a lot of Soviet industry in the wake of Hitler's invasion.
06:21This presented the first big problem for the Americans,
06:25because, you see, the range of the B-29 superfortress,
06:29well, it just wasn't long enough to cover the sheer vastness of Russia.
06:33However, there was a small silver lining.
06:37The upcoming B-36 would have had the necessary range,
06:41which is shown here as the larger, empty sectors on the map.
06:46But it was still in development in 1945,
06:49and it wouldn't become operational until three years later.
06:53Considering the widely dispersed nature of Soviet industry,
06:57the number of nuclear bombs required to destroy it was high.
07:02The planners worked under the assumption that they'd have access to bombs with similar capabilities
07:07to those of Little Boy and Fat Man.
07:10The bombs dropped on Japan, which was a correct assumption,
07:14since they wouldn't be replaced by thermonuclear bombs until 1952.
07:19With first-generation nukes,
07:21it was estimated that three bombs would be needed per city.
07:25So, a full nuclear decapitation strike would require around 200 bombs.
07:33Another 10 bombs were reserved for targeting hypothetical Soviet military bases in the Western Hemisphere,
07:40like the one that would eventually appear on Cuba.
07:43And a final 10 bombs were planned for strategic isolation of the battlefield,
07:48or, in other words, disrupting Soviet logistics.
07:51In practical terms, that would mean blowing up the Bosphorus and the Kiel and the Suez canals.
07:59The international response to such a move was beyond the scope of the study.
08:04Assuming an optimistic 50% success rate,
08:07the Americans estimated that 400 nuclear bombs would be necessary to vanquish the Soviets.
08:14Even ignoring the domestic opposition to such a move,
08:17by the time the U.S. had amassed that many weapons,
08:19the Soviets had already geared up,
08:22and the paranoid era of nuclear deterrence had already taken hold.
08:28Luckily, nuclear war hasn't happened since then,
08:31and hopefully it never will.
08:33For as long as it doesn't happen,
08:35we here at SideQuest will continue diligently exploring the lesser-known parts of world history.
08:42In the meantime, we extend our sincerest gratitude to our wonderful patrons,
08:47and we ask you to stay tuned for the next unthinkably contingent episode of SideQuest.
08:58SideQuest UK
08:59leven
08:59You

Recommended