What Patton Did When Montgomery Was Still Preparing To Cross The Rhine

Name: What Patton Did When Montgomery Was Still Preparing To Cross The Rhine
Uploaded: 2026-07-19T14:10:30+00:00
Duration: 37 min 13 s
Channel: WW2 Dossier

00:00Possibly an entire airborne army dropped behind the far bank just to give the assault troops a

00:05chance. And here were 500 boats sliding into the water without a single shell fired in support.

00:11Colonel Paul J. Black, commanding the 11th Infantry, had received his orders from division

00:16headquarters that morning. Not weeks ago, not days ago, that morning. His 3rd battalion would

00:22cross at Nierstein, his 1st battalion at Oppenheim, one mile upstream. 13 artillery battalions stood

00:29behind them, loaded and aimed. But they were under strict orders not to fire unless the

00:34Germans fired first. The entire plan, if you could call it a plan, depended on one bet, that the enemy

00:40did not know they were coming. At 2200 hours, the 1st boats pushed off. The current was slow,

00:472.5 miles an hour. The water was cold and black. And the men paddled toward a country that had

00:53been

00:53at war for 6 years. Toward a riverbank that might hold anything. Machine guns. Mines. A panzer

01:00division dug in behind the levee. If you find this channel's deep dives into history valuable,

01:04a like and subscribe helps these stories reach the audience they deserve.

01:09Here is what makes that night almost impossible to believe.

01:12100 miles to the north, the most powerful military force ever assembled for a river crossing

01:18was preparing to attack the same river. Field Marshal Bernard Montgomery had spent 6 months

01:23building an operation so large it would be compared to D-Day itself. His plan had a name,

01:29Operation Plunder. It had a supporting airborne assault with its own name, Operation Varsity.

01:35It had 1.2 million soldiers, more than 5,000 artillery pieces, and a smoke screen that stretched 66 miles

01:43along the western bank of the Rhine. British and American engineers, nearly 60,000 of them,

01:49had rehearsed bridge construction on rivers in Belgium. Every road in the rear area was clogged

01:54with convoys carrying ammunition, pontoons, and assault boats. The Second British Army alone

02:00had stockpiled 60,000 tons of ammunition. Montgomery would leave nothing to chance. Nothing.

02:07And 100 miles south of all that, a three-star American general looked at the same river

02:12and decided that 500 plywood boats and a bright moon were enough. This is the story of what happened

02:19next, how George Patton's Third Army crossed the Rhine in a single night with no bombardment,

02:24no air cover, and no permission, while Montgomery was still counting his shells. But it is also a story

02:31about something deeper than rivalry, because the question this night really answers is not who crossed

02:36first. The question is, what happens when two completely different ideas about war

02:41meet the same obstacle. And one of them turns out to need a million men, and the other turns out

02:46to

02:47need 20 casualties and a telephone call. To understand why Patton gambled everything on speed

02:52that night, you have to understand what the Rhine meant in March of 1945. Not just as a river,

02:58but as an idea. Because Montgomery wasn't being cautious for no reason. He had studied what rivers do to

03:04armies. He had watched the disaster at Arnhem six months earlier. He knew exactly what the Rhine could cost.

03:10And that knowledge, that very reasonable, very well-founded knowledge, is precisely what Patton

03:16decided to ignore. In September 1944, the Allies had tried to jump the Rhine from the sky.

03:23Operation Market Garden, Montgomery's plan to drop three airborne divisions across the rivers of Holland

03:28and seize a bridge over the Rhine at Arnhem, had ended in catastrophe. The British first airborne division

03:34landed too far from the bridge. German panzers that intelligence had missed tore into the lightly armed

03:40paratroopers. Of more than 10,000 men who dropped at Arnhem, fewer than 2,400 came back. The rest were

03:48killed, wounded, or captured. The bridge was never taken. That failure did something to Allied planning

03:54that no German counterattack could have done. It made the Rhine sacred. Not sacred like a symbol, sacred like a

04:01warning. Every staff officer who sat down to plan a crossing after Arnhem carried the same unspoken

04:07thought. This river eats armies that come unprepared. Montgomery drew the obvious conclusion. If Arnhem

04:13failed because of insufficient force, then the next crossing would succeed through overwhelming force.

04:19He would not jump the Rhine. He would crush it. Operation Plunder would be the most meticulously prepared

04:25river assault in the history of warfare. And he would not move until every variable was accounted for.

04:31Every gun in position. Every engineer rehearsed. Every contingency planned. The Rhine at Vaisel,

04:38where Montgomery intended to cross, was 400 yards wide. Nearly twice as wide as at Oppenheim. The

04:44current was stronger. The German first parachute army, battered but still dangerous, held the far bank.

04:50Montgomery was not wrong to prepare. He was not wrong to be careful. Remember that. Because what

04:56Patton did only makes sense if you understand that Montgomery's caution was rational. Now hold that

05:01thought. Because two weeks before Patton's boats touched the water at Nierstein, something happened

05:0670 miles to the north that changed the entire equation. On March 7, 1945, a lieutenant from the 9th

05:13Armored Division was leading a patrol toward the Rhine near a town called Remagen. What he saw made him stop

05:19and

05:20radio his commander. The Ludendorff Railroad Bridge, a steel span 980 feet long, was still standing.

05:27Every other bridge on the Rhine had been blown. The Germans had wired Remagen with demolitions.

05:32They had tried to detonate them. The charges had partially fired. The bridge had shuttered and lifted.

05:38But it held. Within hours, American infantry was sprinting across under fire. And by nightfall,

05:44the First Army had troops on the east bank of the Rhine. Remagen was not planned. It was not prepared.

05:50It was a sergeant noticing a bridge. A lieutenant making a call. A captain ordering his men across

05:55before anyone could tell him not to. And it worked. The news hit every headquarters in Europe like a

06:01thunderclap. Eisenhower was elated. Montgomery, still weeks away from plunder, said nothing publicly.

06:07But the message was impossible to miss. The Rhine could be crossed without a million-man operation.

06:12It could be crossed by men who moved faster than the enemy could react. No one heard that message

06:18louder than George Patton. Patton's Third Army had been racing east since January. They had smashed

06:23through the Siegfried Line, cleared the Saar Palatinate, and captured 140,000 German prisoners

06:29in less than two months. His lead unit, the 5th Infantry Division, had crossed so many rivers since Normandy

06:35that Patton would later write they must have webbed feet. The Seine, the Marne, the Moselle,

06:41the Sauer, the Kille. The Red Diamond Division had assaulted every one of them, often at night,

06:47often without heavy preparation. And they had never failed. By mid-March, Patton's forward units were

06:53approaching the Rhine near Mainz. German resistance was collapsing. Entire units were surrendering without

06:59firing a shot. The 7th German Army, responsible for defending more than 50 miles of the Rhine south

07:05of Mainz, had been shattered in the Saar Palatinate and was trying to reorganize behind the river with

07:10almost nothing left. Its commander, General Hans Felber, had two understrength regiments,

07:16two light artillery batteries, and no communication with the army to his south. Patton looked at that

07:22gap, and he saw Remagen all over again. Not a bridge this time. There were no bridges left. But the

07:29same

07:29principle. Speed. Surprise. A crossing before the enemy could recover. There was one problem.

07:36Montgomery's Operation Plunder was scheduled for the night of March 23rd. Eisenhower had designated it

07:42as the main effort. Every eye in the Allied command was fixed on Montgomery's sector. And there was an

07:48unspoken understanding, perhaps an explicit one, that no one was to steal Montgomery's thunder. Not

07:54again. Not after Remagen had already taken the shine off. Patton did not care. He called Omar Bradley,

08:01commander of the 12th Army Group. And Bradley, who understood Patton better than anyone, gave him

08:06four words that changed everything. Take the Rhine on the run. Bradley's order reached Patton on March 19th.

08:13Patton had four days. Maybe three. Because if Montgomery's plunder launched on the night of the 23rd,

08:20and Patton's men were not already on the East Bank by then, the story would be Montgomery's. The

08:25headlines. The newsreels. The history books. All Montgomery's. But Patton was not thinking about

08:31headlines. Not yet. He was thinking about a map. The obvious crossing point was Mainz. A major rail junction.

08:38Good roads on both sides. The kind of place armies had crossed rivers for centuries. Which meant it was

08:44exactly the kind of place the Germans would expect him. Even a shattered army puts whatever it has left

08:50at the obvious points. Patton looked south along the Rhine and found Oppenheim, a small town ten miles

08:56upstream from Mainz, where the river narrowed slightly and the west bank rose high enough to give his artillery

09:02observers a clear view of the flat ground beyond. If he could cross there while the Germans watched

09:08Mainz, the far bank might be empty. He called Manton Eddy, his 12th Corps commander. Put the 5th

09:14division on the Rhine at Oppenheim. And start the 90th division on a feint at Mainz. Smoke screens.

09:20Radio chatter. Visible preparations. Make it look like Mainz is the target. Eddy relayed the order to

09:26General Irwin at 5th division headquarters. Irwin called a meeting of his regimental commanders on

09:32the morning of March 21st. Before they could sit down, Irwin was summoned to Corps headquarters.

09:38When he came back, his face told them everything. The 5th division was going to cross the Rhine.

09:43Irwin's officers expected that much. What they did not expect was the timing. Irwin told them to be ready

09:49to go that same night, March 21st. The magnitude of the task was staggering. Assault boats,

09:56bridging equipment, engineer stores. All of it was in depots in Lorraine, a hundred miles to the rear.

10:03Convoys had to be organized, roads cleared, boats trucked forward, engineers briefed. A proper river

10:09assault against the Rhine required days of preparation at minimum. Irwin believed Patton would not actually

10:15order them across until the 23rd. But he told his commanders to prepare as if it were tonight.

10:21The next 36 hours became a logistics sprint that would have been impossible for any division that

10:26had not already crossed half a dozen rivers under fire. Convoys carrying 500 assault boats rolled

10:32forward from depots that had been stocked since the previous autumn. Bradley's staff had been quietly

10:37building reserves of bridging equipment in Lorraine since September, anticipating exactly this moment.

10:42The 204th Engineer Combat Battalion moved into Nierstein and Oppenheim and began scouting launch

10:49sites. Artillery observers climbed the hills on the west bank and registered their guns on the far

10:54shore. And the men of the 11th Infantry, the regiment that would lead the assault, cleaned their weapons

11:00and waited. On the morning of March 22nd, Eddie called Irwin. Patton wants the crossing tonight.

11:05Irwin pushed back. It was impossible, he said, to mount a well-planned and ordered crossing in the

11:11hours remaining. There was not enough time to coordinate artillery, not enough time to rehearse

11:16the engineers, not enough time to do any of the things that Doctrine said you had to do before

11:21sending infantry across 800 feet of open water against an unknown defense. Eddie listened. Then he

11:27asked, can you get some sort of bridgehead? Irwin paused. Some sort of bridgehead. That was not a plan,

11:34that was a gamble. It meant putting men into boats with no preparatory fire, no suppression of the far bank,

11:40no guarantee of anything except that they would reach the other side wet and alive or wet and dead.

11:46Yes, Irwin said. He could get some sort of bridgehead. That was all Patton needed to hear.

11:51By noon, Colonel Paul Black at the 11th Infantry had his orders. 3rd Battalion crosses at Nierstein,

11:581st Battalion at Oppenheim, H-Hour 2200. Thirteen artillery battalions will be loaded and aimed,

12:04but will not fire unless the Germans shoot first. Surprise is the only advantage you have. Do not

12:10waste it. That afternoon, something strange happened. The men of the 11th Infantry walked

12:15through Nierstein and looked across the Rhine, and saw almost nothing. An occasional mortar shell

12:21dropped into the streets. A few artillery rounds hit empty lots. But the far bank was quiet. No movement,

12:27no vehicle traffic, no sound of digging. American artillery observers scanned the eastern shore with

12:33binoculars and found nothing worth shooting at. They did not know it yet, but the German 7th Army barely existed.

12:40Field Marshal Kesselring had authorized withdrawal behind the Rhine only two days earlier,

12:45and General Felber's headquarters was still trying to locate its own units. The 13th Corps sector opposite

12:50Oppenheim was held by fragments. Men who had walked out of the Tsar Palatinate without vehicles,

12:55without heavy weapons, many without officers. The chances of rappelling a crossing, one German

13:01report later admitted, were pathetically meager. But the men climbing into those boats at 10 o'clock

13:06that night did not know any of that. All they knew was the moon, the river, and the silence. And

13:12the

13:12silence was the worst part. Because silence on a riverbank at night, in a war, means one of two things.

13:18It means the enemy is not there. Or it means the enemy is waiting for you to reach the middle

13:22of the

13:22water, before he opens up with everything he has. The 3rd Battalion pushed off first. Company K in the

13:28lead boats. Twelve men per boat, paddling with their hands and rifle butts because there were not enough

13:34paddles to go around. The current caught them immediately. Not fast, but steady, pulling them

13:39downstream. And they had to fight it while staying low, while keeping quiet, while watching the far bank

13:44for the muzzle flash that would mean the end of surprise. The moon was directly above them. Every man in

13:50those boats was a silhouette on silver water. If a single German machine gunner was awake and watching

13:55from the east bank, one burst of fire would turn the crossing into a massacre. Plywood and canvas do not

14:01stop bullets. They do not even slow them down. The boats reached the east bank. Nothing happened. Men

14:07scrambled over the gunwales, soaked to the chest, and clawed up the muddy slope with their rifles. The first thing

14:14they found was seven German soldiers standing with their hands in the air. These men had not been hiding. They

14:19had not been

14:20waiting in ambush. They had been asleep. They did not know an American army was crossing the Rhine.

14:25They surrendered because they looked up and saw men with M1 rifles standing over them and had no idea

14:31where they had come from. Within minutes, Company K had a foothold. Within an hour, the entire 3rd

14:37battalion was across. The 1st battalion followed at Oppenheim and met scattered fire. A few rifle shots,

14:44a burst of machine gun, then silence again. By midnight, the engineers were bringing empty boats

14:49back to the west bank and loading them with the next wave. The 10th Infantry Regiment started

14:55crossing behind the 11th, then the 2nd Infantry. And here is the number that tells the story of that

15:00night. By dawn on March 23rd, roughly seven hours after the first boat touched the east bank,

15:06on the evening of March 23rd, roughly 20 hours after Patton's men had already secured a bridgehead

15:11six miles deep, Montgomery's Operation Plunder began. At five o'clock in the afternoon, the artillery

15:18opened. 4,000 guns along a 20-mile front. The bombardment lasted four hours. Shells screamed across

15:25the Rhine in such density that soldiers on the west bank could not hear each other speak. The ground shook

15:31for miles. Private Glenn Tomlin of the Canadian Highland Light Infantry, 21 years old, from Clinton,

15:38Ontario, described the sound as a continuous roar, individual detonations blurring into one sustained

15:44wall of noise that did not pause, did not dip, did not stop. The air above the river was a

15:51ceiling of

15:51steel. At nine o'clock that night, the 51st Highland Division pushed off in storm boats near Rees.

15:57Behind them, the 15th Scottish Division. Behind the Scots, the British Commando Brigade heading for

16:03Weasel. Behind the commandos, the American 30th Infantry Division and the 79th. The river at Weasel

16:10was 400 yards of open water under German artillery fire. Storm boats capsized. Men drowned. Mortar rounds

16:18found their marks. But the British and Americans kept crossing, wave after wave, boat after boat,

16:24boat. And by midnight, they had footholds on the east bank. Then came the morning. March 24th. Dawn.

16:3116,000 paratroopers of the 17th American Airborne Division and the 6th British Airborne Division

16:38climbed into 1,600 transport aircraft and 1,300 gliders. Operation Varsity, the largest single-lift

16:47airborne assault ever attempted, rose into the sky over Belgium and France, turned east, and headed for the

16:53Rhine. Their mission was to land directly on top of the German positions behind the river,

16:58seize the high ground, and prevent any counterattack from hitting the bridgeheads before the engineers

17:04could build their bridges. The aircraft crossed the Rhine at low altitude, in daylight, in full view

17:09of every German anti-aircraft gun still functioning in the sector. The sky filled with flack. Transport

17:16planes were hit, caught fire, broke apart. Gliders took rounds through their plywood fuselages,

17:22and slammed into fields at 70 miles an hour. Paratroopers jumped into fire before their canopies

17:28fully opened. In the fields east of Wessel, men landed on top of German positions and fought hand

17:34to hand within seconds of touching the ground. By the end of March 24th, Operation Varsity had achieved

17:40its objectives. The airborne troops held their ground. The bridgeheads were secure. Montgomery's crossing was a

17:47success. The cost? 1,111 Allied soldiers killed in a single day. Total casualties for plunder and varsity

17:55combined? 6,781 men. Hold that number. 6,700 casualties. Against Patton's 20, the comparison is blunt,

18:06and it is uncomfortable, because it suggests something that neither the British nor the American

18:10official histories were eager to say directly. Montgomery's operation worked. It achieved

18:16everything it was designed to achieve. The Rhine was crossed. The bridgeheads were held. The advance

18:22into northern Germany was launched. By any conventional military standard, plunder was a triumph. But Patton

18:28had already done the same thing, at Oppenheim, with a fraction of the force, at a fraction of the cost,

18:34a full day earlier. And the question that no after-action report could answer,

18:39was whether Montgomery's 6,000 casualties bought something that Patton's 20 casualties did not.

18:45Patton certainly knew the answer. And on the morning of March 23rd, before plunder even began,

18:51he picked up the phone. The call went to Omar Bradley at 12th Army Group Headquarters.

18:56Patton's voice was low, almost conspiratorial. The tone was unlike him. George Patton did not whisper,

19:02Brad, don't tell anyone, but I'm across. Bradley paused. Across what? Across the Rhine. I sneaked a

19:10division over last night. But there are so few krauts around there they don't know it yet. So don't

19:15make any announcement. We'll keep it a secret until we see how it goes. Bradley said nothing for a moment.

19:21Then, well, I'll be damned. That was the morning call. The quiet one. The one where Patton played it

19:28careful, checking that the bridgehead would hold before he made it public, making sure the Germans

19:33had not counterattacked, making sure the bridge was going up. For twelve hours he waited. Patton,

19:40a man who had never waited for anything in his life if he could help it, waited. Then the evening

19:45came. The bridge was open. Tanks were rolling across. Four divisions were moving east. And one

19:51hundred miles north, the first waves of plunder were pushing off into the Rhine. Patton called Bradley

19:57again. This time he did not whisper. Brad, for God's sake, tell the world we're across.

20:02I want the world to know Third Army made it before Monty starts across.

20:06Bradley released the news to the press at a time, as he later admitted, calculated to take some of

20:12the luster from the news of Montgomery's crossing. By the time the morning papers carried the story of

20:17plunder, the massive bombardment, the airborne drop, the thousand guns, they also carried a smaller story

20:24from further south. An American general had crossed the Rhine in plywood boats. No bombardment. No

20:30paratroopers. No losses worth counting. The rivalry between the two men was real. And it was old. And it

20:37went back to Sicily in 1943. But what happened on March 23rd was not about ego. Or rather, it was

20:44about

20:45ego, but ego in the service of something larger. Because Patton's phone call did not just embarrass

20:50Montgomery. It asked a question that the Allied High Command had been avoiding for months. If this

20:56river could be crossed by 500 boats, in surprise, what exactly were the other million men for?

21:01The answer to that question arrived the next morning, on a pontoon bridge at Oppenheim. And it

21:07arrived wearing cavalry boots and a pair of ivory-handled pistols. March 24th, 1945. Patton's jeep rolled onto the

21:15floating bridge around midday. The structure swayed gently under the weight of vehicles. 366 meters of

21:22linked pontoons, bobbing in the current, steel treads clanking as tanks crossed in single file.

21:28Engineers were still working the far end. Patton told his driver to stop in the middle. He stepped

21:33out of the jeep. He stood on the bridge with the Rhine flowing beneath his boots. The east bank of

21:38Germany

21:38ahead. The war behind him. The sun, high. His aide, Lieutenant Colonel Charles Codman, stood nearby.

21:45An army photographer raised his camera. Patton unzipped his fly. I've been looking forward to

21:50this for a long time, he said. And he urinated into the Rhine while the photographer recorded

21:55the moment for the official record. It was not dignified. It was not what a three-star general

22:00was supposed to do in front of his men and a camera. But Patton was not performing for the army.

22:05He was performing for history. He had read enough of it to know that great crossings demanded great

22:10gestures. And he had chosen his gesture months ago, possibly years ago. He finished, zipped up,

22:17climbed back into the jeep, and rode to the east bank, where he deliberately stumbled. He caught

22:22himself with both hands, scooped up two fistfuls of German soil, and rose holding them above his head.

22:28Thus, William the Conqueror. In 1066, William of Normandy had tripped and fallen face first onto the

22:35beach of England as his army landed for the invasion. His men gasped, a bad omen. William

22:41stood up with English soil in his hands and declared that he had seized possession of the land.

22:46His men cheered. The omen became a prophecy. Patton, who had studied William his entire life,

22:51who had named his own bull terrier, William the Conqueror, before the dog showed cowardice under

22:56shell fire and had to be renamed Willie, knew the story by heart. He had waited 60 years to reenact

23:03it.

23:03That evening, he sent a message to Supreme Headquarters Allied Expeditionary Force.

23:08Dear Schaaf, I have just pissed into the Rhine River. For God's sake, send some gasoline.

23:14The gasoline arrived, and what Patton did with it over the following week erased any remaining doubt

23:20about what the crossing at Oppenheim meant. The 5th Division's bridgehead was never seriously

23:25threatened. The German 7th Army attempted a counterattack on the 23rd. Hitler himself ordered it

23:31from his bunker in Berlin. But General Felber reported back that no reserve forces were available.

23:37There was nothing to counterattack with. The Americans simply walked east.

23:41By March 25th, the 12th Corps bridgehead was 20 miles deep. The 4th Armored Division was already

23:47bypassing Frankfurt, racing northeast toward the Mine River. Behind them came the 90th Infantry,

23:53the 76th, the 11th Armored. And Patton was not finished with the Rhine. Even as his 12th Corps

23:59expanded east from Oppenheim, he launched three more crossings. The 87th Infantry Division assaulted

24:05at Beaupard on March 25th. The next night, more troops crossed at St. Gore, in the shadow of the

24:11Lorelei Rock, in a stretch of river so narrow and fast that the Germans thought no army would attempt it.

24:17On March 28th, the 80th Division crossed at Mines. All four crossings succeeded without preparatory

24:24artillery fire. Not one of them had been planned more than 72 hours in advance. By the end of March,

24:30Patton's 3rd Army had captured 300,000 prisoners and was advancing so fast that his forward units were

24:37outrunning their own supply lines. The Rhine, the barrier that was supposed to cost a campaign,

24:43had cost him a single night. Now step back and look at the map.

24:46By March 28th, five days after plunder, both crossings had achieved their strategic objectives.

24:53Montgomery's forces were across in the north, driving toward Hamburg and the North German Plain.

24:58Patton's forces were across in the south, driving toward Kassel and central Germany.

25:03Eisenhower's plan for multiple crossings had worked exactly as designed. But something had changed that

25:09could not be found on any operations map. Montgomery had crossed the Rhine the way the Allied command

25:14expected, with overwhelming force, careful preparation, and acceptable losses. Patton had crossed it the

25:21way no one expected, with speed, surprise, and losses so small they looked like a clerical error. And the

25:28men who noticed that difference most were not the generals. They were the soldiers.

25:32Sergeant Michael Builder, of the 5th Infantry Division, wrote it plainly in his memoir.

25:37We may not have cared for Patton, he said, but we liked Montgomery even less. Patton could at least

25:43justify his prima donna attitude with results. Montgomery was far too cautious and seemed to

25:49plod along. Monty would not attack until he had overwhelming superiority, and even then he advanced in

25:55inches. That judgment, from an enlisted man who had no stake in the rivalry, who simply wanted to survive

26:00the war, cuts deeper than any official assessment. Because Builder was not comparing strategies,

26:06he was comparing something more fundamental. He was comparing what it felt like to serve under a general

26:12who trusted speed, and what it felt like to watch another general who trusted preparation. And he had

26:17decided, the way soldiers always decide, not with analysis but with their feet and their gut, that speed

26:23was the one that kept more of them alive. Whether he was right is a question historians have argued about

26:29for eighty years. But there is one fact that no argument can touch. Patton's Rhine crossing cost

26:34twenty casualties. Montgomery's cost sixty seven hundred. And both of them ended up on the same

26:40side of the river. There is a temptation to end the story there, with the numbers, with the contrast,

26:46with Patton standing on the east bank holding German soil. It would be a clean ending. The bold general

26:52beats the cautious one. Speed wins. Case closed. But that is not what happened. What happened is more

26:58complicated and more interesting. And it starts with a question that Patton himself never asked.

27:04At least, not out loud. Why did Eisenhower let him do it? Bradley gave Patton the order to take the

27:10Rhine on the run. But Bradley answered to Eisenhower. And Eisenhower had spent months managing the most

27:15delicate coalition in military history. An alliance in which the British and Americans disagreed about

27:20almost everything. From strategy, to supply priorities, to who deserved the glory.

27:27Montgomery's plunder was designated the main effort. The entire Allied plan for crossing the Rhine was

27:33built around Montgomery's timetable. A rogue American crossing that embarrassed the British field marshal

27:38could have fractured the alliance at the worst possible moment. Eisenhower knew what Patton was going to

27:44do. He had to have known. Bradley would not have issued the order without Eisenhower's quiet approval.

27:50And Eisenhower would not have given that approval without calculating exactly what it would mean,

27:54strategically and politically. The supreme commander wanted multiple crossings. He wanted the Germans

28:00stretched thin along 500 miles of river, unable to concentrate against any single point. Montgomery's

28:06crossing in the north and Patton's crossing in the south were not competing operations. They were

28:12complementary ones. Eisenhower needed both. But he also understood something subtler. He understood that

28:18the way Patton crossed mattered as much as the fact that he crossed. A surprise assault with no

28:22bombardment, no airborne drop, no six-month buildup. That sent a message to the German high command that no

28:29amount of artillery could send. It said, We can cross your last barrier anywhere, anytime, with whatever we

28:36have on hand. You cannot predict us. You cannot prepare for us. You are finished.

28:42Hitler received the news in his bunker. He ordered a counterattack at Oppenheim. His staff told him there

28:47were no forces available. That exchange, the Fuhrer demanding action, his generals admitting they had

28:54nothing left to act with, was the Rhine crossing in miniature. The river had not stopped the Americans,

28:59it had not even slowed them, and the fortification that was supposed to buy Germany Weeks had bought it

29:05nothing at all. The deeper lesson of March 22nd is not about Patton versus Montgomery. It is about what

29:11happens when an institution's greatest strength becomes its greatest weakness. Montgomery's method,

29:17meticulous planning, overwhelming force, systematic execution, had won at El Alamein. It had worked at the

29:24Rhine. By any historical standard, it was a proven way to fight a war. But proven methods carry a hidden

29:30cost. They take time. And time is not a neutral resource. Time belongs to whoever uses it better.

29:37And by March of 1945, the Germans were using every hour the Allies gave them. Patton saw that. He saw

29:45it

29:45not because he was smarter than Montgomery, there is no evidence he was, but because he was built

29:50differently. His instinct was to act before the picture was complete. Montgomery's instinct was

29:55to complete the picture before he acted. In 1942, Montgomery's instinct was the right one.

30:02The Allies were weaker, less experienced, less certain. Preparation saved them. By 1945, the situation

30:09had reversed. The Allies were overwhelmingly stronger, and the enemy was collapsing. Preparation did not save

30:15men anymore. It cost them, because every day of preparation was a day the enemy used to scrape

30:21together one more gun, one more minefield, one more battalion of teenagers and old men,

30:26willing to die for a cause that was already lost. 20 casualties versus 6,700. Those numbers are not a

30:33verdict on Montgomery's generalship. They are a verdict on timing. Patton crossed at the right moment, the

30:39precise moment when the German defense at Oppenheim had dissolved, but not yet reformed. Twelve hours earlier,

30:45the boats might not have been there. Twelve hours later, and Felber might have found a regiment to

30:50put on the bank. The window was open for exactly one night, and Patton, through instinct, through

30:55rivalry, through sheer inability to sit still, put his men through it. Montgomery, facing a stronger

31:01defense on a wider river, did not have the same window. His casualties were not the price of caution.

31:07They were the price of a harder problem. But the perception, the story the soldiers told,

31:11the story the newspapers printed, the story that history remembers, is simpler and more brutal.

31:17One general crossed with boats in surprise. The other crossed with a million men and 6,000 dead.

31:23On the morning of March 23, Eisenhower wrote Patton a letter. He had written many letters to many

31:29generals during the war. This one was different.

31:31I have frequently had occasion to state my appreciation of the great accomplishments of

31:36this allied force, Eisenhower wrote. The purpose of this note is to express to you personally

31:41my deep appreciation of the splendid way in which you have conducted Third Army operations,

31:46from the moment it entered battle last August. You have made your army a fighting force that has

31:51not excelled in effectiveness by any other of equal size in the world. Not excelled by any other of equal

31:57size in the world. From the supreme commander, who weighed every word, who balanced every compliment,

32:02who spent his career making sure no single general received too much praise at the expense of the

32:08coalition. That sentence was as close to a verdict as Dwight Eisenhower would ever deliver. He never

32:14said anything comparable about Operation Plunder. And Patton, who saved every letter, who recorded every

32:20slight, who measured his legacy against Caesar and Napoleon and Hannibal. Patton read that sentence and

32:27wrote to his wife that night, I am scared by my good luck. Nine months later, on a road outside

32:32Mannheim, not far from the stretch of Rhine his men had crossed in plywood boats,

32:37George Patton's staff car was struck by a truck. He broke his neck. He lay in a hospital in Heidelberg

32:43for twelve days, paralyzed from the neck down. His last words, spoken to his wife on the evening of

32:49December 21, 1945, were quiet ones. It's so dark, so late. The pontoon bridge at Oppenheim is gone now.

32:58The Rhine flows through Nierstein the way it did before the war, wide, slow, indifferent to what

33:05men once asked of it. The vineyards still run down to the water's edge. On a warm evening,

33:10from the hills on the west bank, you can see the flat ground stretching east beyond the river,

33:15the same ground that American artillery observers scanned through binoculars on the afternoon of March 22,

33:221945, looking for targets and finding none. The 5th Infantry Division came home in the summer of 45.

33:29General Irwin, who had protested that a proper crossing was impossible, and then delivered one

33:34anyway, returned to a career that never quite matched the scale of what his Red Diamond Division had done.

33:40He retired as a Major General in 1953. Colonel Paul Black, who had received his orders to cross the

33:46Rhine the same morning he was expected to execute them, served out the occupation, and left the army

33:52quietly. The division itself was eventually deactivated in 1992, re-flagged, reorganized,

33:58folded into a bureaucratic reshuffling that erased its name from the active roles. The Red Diamond

34:04Shoulder Patch, chosen decades earlier because the Diamond Dies Company's slogan, It Never Runs, carried a

34:11second meaning in wartime, went into museums and scrapbooks, and the dresser drawers of old men who

34:16remembered what it meant to carry assault boats down a vineyard in the dark. Montgomery's Operation

34:21Plunder achieved everything it was designed to achieve. His forces crossed the Rhine, broke through

34:27the German First Parachute Army, and drove north into the heartland of a dying Reich. The airborne troops

34:32of Varsity held their ground at terrible cost, and the bridges they fought to protect carried a million

34:38men into Germany. Montgomery ended the war as one of Britain's most celebrated commanders,

34:43received his Field Marshal's baton, and spent the next four decades defending every decision

34:48he ever made. He never acknowledged, publicly or privately, that Patton's crossing had changed

34:53anything. Patton never got the chance to write his version. He died nine months after the war ended,

34:59on a road in Germany, in a collision that should not have killed him, but did. He was 60 years

35:04old.

35:04He had spent his entire adult life preparing for a war that lasted six years, and he had fought in

35:10it for eleven months. In those eleven months, his Third Army advanced farther, captured more prisoners,

35:16and liberated more territory than any comparable force in the European theatre. He crossed the Rhine

35:22in plywood boats on a night when the moon was too bright, the plan was too thin, and the window

35:27was

35:27exactly wide enough for a man who refused to wait. The men who paddled those boats, the riflemen of Company

35:33K,

35:3311th Infantry, 3rd Battalion, 5th Infantry Division, were the first soldiers of Patton's army to touch the

35:39east bank of the Rhine. Most of them were in their early twenties, some were teenagers. They had crossed

35:45the Seine, the Marne, the Moselle, the Sauer, and the Kille before they reached the river that was

35:51supposed to stop them. It did not stop them. Nothing stopped them. They climbed the bank, found seven German

35:57soldiers who did not know the war had come to their stretch of river, accepted their surrender,

36:02and kept moving east. None of them made a speech. None of them unzipped their fly on a bridge for

36:08a

36:08photographer. None of them scooped up soil and invoked William the Conqueror. They did what infantrymen

36:13do. They got out of the boat, walked forward, and waited for someone to shoot at them. When no one

36:19did,

36:19they kept walking. That is what Patton did when Montgomery was still preparing to cross the Rhine.

36:24He put men in boats. Not a million men. Not 5,000 guns. Not 16,000 paratroopers. Just men in

36:32boats,

36:33on a river, in the dark. And he trusted them to do the rest. Sometimes the most powerful thing a

36:38general can do is not prepare more. It is decide that what he already has is enough.

36:44Thank you for watching this one all the way through. If you're still here after 50 minutes,

36:49you're the kind of viewer who makes this channel possible, and I mean that. A like helps this story reach

36:54the people who care about it. If you haven't subscribed yet, now is a good time. And hit

36:59that bell so you don't miss what's coming next. I'd love to know where you're watching from.

37:03Drop your country in the comments, and if someone in your family served in the Second World War,

37:08tell us about them. Their stories matter, and this is a place where people still want to hear them.

What Patton Did When Montgomery Was Still Preparing To Cross The Rhine

Category

Transcript

Recommended